Holiday PDP Prompt: We Didn’t Guess. We Asked.

Craig Kistler
November 1, 2025

In this holiday PDP prompt case study, we asked returning visitors ‘Shopping for a gift?’ on the product-detail page and created a curated path when the current product wasn’t it.

The moment

Holiday traffic was landing on PDPs with low intent. A gift guide existed, but the path to it wasn’t obvious from the product page.

holiday PDP prompt case study screenshot showing ‘Shopping for a gift?’ prompt on product page

The bet

Ask a simple question on the PDP—“Shopping for a gift?”—and give people a curated path when the current product isn’t it.

The setup

  • Split: default vs. PDP with a small holiday prompt and subtle icon motion
  • Placement: near the buy stack, always below price and above secondary content
  • Primary KPIs: CTR, Conversion, RPV, AOV

What happened

The prompt earned low-friction engagement and nudged people into the right aisle. We saw AOV, ATC, and RPV rise. Importantly, visitors who tapped No also stayed longer and viewed more items. Feeling understood led to more exploration.

Why it worked

  • Relevance over pressure. The prompt met shoppers where they were and offered a helpful detour instead of forcing a decision.
  • Intent alignment. During gifting season, many PDP landings are mismatches. A curated door reduces dead ends.

Design Choices That Mattered

  • Keep the prompt compact and near the buy stack
  • Use calm motion to earn attention without shouting
  • Send to a tightly merchandised destination (not a catch-all page)

According to recent research on mobile shopping, pulling a user out of flow with an interruption that’s relevant to their task can reduce decision efficiency.

Guardrails

  • Seasonal only; suppress outside the holiday window
  • Honor hesitation signals; avoid stacking with other attention-grabbers on the PDP
  • Track downstream behavior from both Yes and No paths

Takeaway

Personalization starts when you stop assuming. Not every lift comes from prediction. Sometimes it comes from asking the right question at the right time.

Explore more results

Want to see all case studies? Visit our full case study library

Ready to Make Every Visit Count?

Let’s turn your site into a smarter, faster, more profitable growth engine — one signal at a time.

330.241.9357